Menu of The Empanada Spot in Farmingdale, New York, USA

Menu Overview

The Empanada Spot, located at 850b Main St, Farmingdale, NY, is a hidden gem for empanada lovers craving authentic, freshly made Colombian flavors. From the moment you step into this immaculately clean and warmly welcoming space, you know you’re in for a treat. The compact, spotless shop doesn't compromise on quality or variety. Here, empanadas are crafted with care, filled generously, and fried to a perfect crispness, making every bite a satisfying experience.

The menu boasts a well-rounded selection of wheat flour empanadas, each priced reasonably at $3.75. The Chicken Fajita empanada stands out with its tender grilled chicken breast, melted cheese, pepper, and onion — a savory combination that delivers a delightful punch. For those who prefer classic flavors, the shredded Chicken and Ground Beef empanadas are robust, seasoned just right, and deeply comforting. Unique offerings like the Bacon, Macaroni, and Cheese empanada introduce a creative twist on traditional fillings, while the Spinach and Cheese and Greek Empanadas (with feta and mozzarella) provide vegetarian-friendly options that don’t compromise on flavor or texture.

What truly elevates the experience is the inclusion of "Mamis Empanada," a hearty blend of ground beef, egg, and rice — a nod to traditional Colombian ingredients that fills and satisfies. The Italian Sausage empanada adds a savory depth, rounding out the savory options with robust seasoning and rich texture.

For those with a sweet tooth, The Empanada Spot shines with its dessert empanadas. The Sweet Plantain and Cheese and the USA Empanada, featuring apples and cinnamon, offer a comforting, mildly sweet finish. The Caramel and Cheese variant is decadently rich, a perfect balance of gooey and crisp. These creative dessert options not only diversify the menu but also highlight the brand’s culinary versatility.

Accompanying sauces, such as the spicy Green Jalapeno Sauce for just $0.50, add an extra layer of flavor, enhancing the empanadas without overpowering the enduring richness of their fillings.

Customer feedback consistently praises the freshness and crispiness; words like "spot on," "made to order fresh," and "tremendous friendly staff" appear frequently. It’s clear the kitchen’s decades of experience shine through each empanada. The ingredients blend skillfully — from the premium meats to the fresh vegetables and cheeses — ensuring every bite is balanced and flavorsome.

Personally, the crispy texture coupled with the vibrant seasoning left a lasting impression. The Empanada Spot is a triumph in delivering authentic and inventive empanada offerings that satisfy cravings for both traditional and creative savory and sweet bites. For anyone in or around Farmingdale, this restaurant is a must-visit to sample Colombian empanadas that are fresh, flavorful, and affordably priced.

In summary, The Empanada Spot exemplifies how a small, well-managed eatery can craft superior empanadas through fresh ingredients, thoughtful recipes, and attentive service. Its diverse menu and excellent execution make it a reliable favorite for both locals and visitors alike.